Tuesday, October 25 - 0 comments

Methodology of Value Education


Ramakrishna Institute of Moral and Spiritual Education
Yadavagiri, Mysore - 570 020.
in collaboration with
National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE), New Delhi
Two Four-day Residential courses in
Value Orientation in Teacher Education
18-21 and 26-29 December 2001
 
Synopsis of the Guest Speakers

 Methodology of Value Education
Dr. Y.N. Sridhar

 

Concept of Value Education

The phrase `Value Education' as used in the area of school education refers to the study of development of essential values in pupils and the practices suggested for the promotion of the same. In its full range of meaning, value education includes developing the appropriate sensibilities _ moral, cultural, spiritual and the ability to make proper value judgment and internalize them in one's life. It is an education for `becoming' and involves the total personality of the individual. Value education is essentially `Man Making' and `Character Building'.

Methodologies and techniques

The field of value education is as broad as life itself and touches every aspect of human life, personality and education. Whether or not they offer specific programs, educational institutions provide some kind of value education. In many institutions, the curriculum of value education is formal and direct, while in large majority of schools it is informal and indirect. What makes learning and acquisition of values different form other aspect of school curriculum is that learning of values cannot be reduced and restricted to classroom instruction alone. The pupils learning of values in the school is a continuation of their learning in their family, community and through mass media. Therefore, the school should take into cognizance and utilize all types of social and educational influences affecting the development of values in pupils for value education purpose.
The methods and strategies of value education are many and varied the selection of, which depends much upon the values chosen, sources of development of these values and many other limiting factors. The entire school curriculum function as an important sources of value education. The democratic practice and activities sponsored though a student self government contributes effectively for value learning. There is no way in which children can avoid catching values and attitudes form their teachers. Values education in schools, therefore, is effected though direct, indirect, incidental methods. Values get transmitted via both the implicit or hidden and planned curriculum.
The point emphasized is that the entire process of value education is a highly comprehensive and complex one that involves a wide range and variety of learning experiences. All forms of learning cannot be provided though single source or teacher should draw form a variety of learning resources either independently or in combination. With this analysis and understanding background, the following methods and techniques may be suggested.
1. Classroom learning activities methods/approach
2. Practical activities method
3. Socialized techniques and activities
4. Incidental learning method

1. Classroom Learning Activities Method
A very basic purpose of value education is to develop the moral autonomy of the learner and also sensitivities of value content of school and classroom activities. The methods and activities should be free from attempt to indoctrinate the learner. Capacity for value judgment and internalization are to be achieved by exposing students to a variety of experiences and activities. This may include reading, listening, discussions, narration, direct presentation of ideas by the teacher and other strategies. These strategies should be used with any of the following sources of value education (a) Biographies (b) Stories (c) Extracts form essays, articles, classics and news paper (d) Parables, proverbs, quotations and poems (e) value/moral dilemmas (f) classroom incidents/anecdotes/ conflicts. These sources can be used in many different ways to involve the learner in thinking and reasoning about values. The classroom teachers can prepare action plans/lesson plans using these sources, a few illustrations of which are discussed here.
  • BIOGRAPHIES: A biography is a written document on the life history of an eminent personality. Biographies of scientist, social reformers and spiritual leaders acquaint one personality. Biographies of scientist, social reformers and spiritual leaders acquaint one with their life, thoughts, and actions and various forces which moulded their lives as depicted by biographer. For being used as material for value education it should be condensed in such a way as to highlight the virtues and their development in the life of the eminent personality. The entire biography may be retold after rearranging the content bringing together all the related events depicting each one of the values hidden in it. (The steps involved in the use of biographies is given in appendix I.)
  • STORIES: Stories of various kinds are attractive to students of varied age groups. Stories may be presented by the teacher of presented by students themselves, followed by discussions and on questioning and analysis. The teacher should use his direction in selecting the story appropriate to the developmental level of the learner. Simple and short stories such as fairy tales and fables are better suited to elementary level children. Stories could be used to develop value awareness of different kinds. Fables and fairy tales could be used to develop values of kindness, love for living beings, environmental awareness and courage. (The step involved in story telling with illustrations are given in appendix II)
  • EXTRACTS FROM ESSAYS. ARTICLES, CLASSICS AND NEWSPAPERS: Non-fictional writings dealing with value themes, such as essays, articles and news paper reports may be used for value education purpose. These may be scholarly writings on issues of social and national concern appearing in books and journals. Students may be asked to collect articles and writings form various sources, encouraged to write articles on a chosen value theme. Teachers can frame questions that provoke in the learner to think and reflect on many issues of the values covered. (Illustrations form famous works are given appendix III).
  • VALUE/MORAL DILEMMAS FOR DISCUSSIONS: Value or moral dilemmas may be used as an important instructional strategies in value education. They present very effective situations for learners to think, to reason and to make moral judgment and arrive at a decision after considering all issues involved in the moral dilemma. The dilemmas constructed may be on issues like environmental conservation, scientific temper, social justice and equality. A teacher can prepare a lesson or initiate discussion on a dilemma indicating all the essential steps involved. In view of the great potential of dilemmas in developing the capacity for moral judgment moral dilemmas are used as research tools in the study of moral development and judgment in children. The teacher can initiate discussion on the dilemma chosen by giving the pros and cons of the issues involved. The student may be asked to react to each issue with reason. There may be a student leader to monitor/record the proceedings of the discussion (The moral dilemmas and illustrations are given in appendix IV).
2. Practical Activities Method/Approach
Value education merely by cognitive precept is not enough even though it is essential. Children should engage themselves in life related practical activities which will promote the application of principles and values in daily life. The essence of practical approach is that they provide the learners with suitable opportunities to practice and live their lives according to the principles and values they have perceived and understood. Under the rubric of practical activities a wide range of activities may be organized. Practically, all subjects of school curriculum lead to project or practical work and this may be designed as to make it relevant to value education. A sound program of value education may include a combination of a few or all activities mentioned below-
  • School campus/classroom maintenance activities
  • Social forestry/community development activities
  • Work experience related activities
  • Organizing campaigns on community sanitation, literacy, environmental awareness, AIDS prevention awareness
  • Yoga, meditation and prayer sessions
  • Eradication of social evils campaign activities (gender inequality, dowry, alcoholism…)
  • co _ curricular/self government activities Organizing such value related practical activities poses some practical problems to the school. Great care should be taken in planning and organizing practical activities mentioned above.

3. Socialized Techniques/approaches
A variety of group oriented techniques may be used in value education. The learner I socialized techniques is involved in activities and experiences which best represent functions and problems of agents of socialization. The experience the learner gets here is not the same type of experience deriving from direct encounters with reality, nor it is completely indirect and abstract as in the case of cognitive area. They are the simplified versions of real social experiences and one necessary and useful when the reality is too abstract and obscured. These include social role playing enacting and modeling.
The effectiveness of the social experiences planned to promote healthy development among children could be increased with the better understanding of social role playing. Children in various social situations assume some roles. One can understand the interrelationship between the expectations of other and the identification of the self in the social role playing the learner should be guided properly to understand the role behavior and enactment. Role playing activities should be organized based on the life experiences and age level of students. Expected role of an ideal student, teacher, parent, patriot should encourage student to take role taking activities voluntarily. Negative precepts are to be discouraged in role playing.
In simulation activities the learner pretends to be in real situation and portrays events and characteristics in the situation. Modeling is a strategy in which qualities of an individual who is considered to posses desirable or ideal values worth emulating are presented to the learners as a model a broad indication of the kinds of activities possible under the heads of socialized strategies for value education purpose are listed below-
a. Dramatization activities like staging play, dramas, both of traditional folk and modern on value themes.
b. Enacting opportunities to take up and practice the role of different kinds, taking the role form epics/scriptures.
c. Modeling exercise, the ideal persons and groups on themes such as
    1) gender inequality
    2) problems pertaining to women's role and education
    3) caring animals and human beings
    4) problems related to environmental protection
    5) consequences of air water pollution
(Constructing the image through discussions, questioning and developing awareness about the specific problems in the above mentioned areas).

4. Incidental Learning Method
An incident is an episode or experience in the life of an individual or group. The incidental approach has a very good point in its favor in that it can be used both inside as well as outside the classroom for value education purposes. It consists in identifying the wrong or right actions of an individual or group, either pre-planned to occur or observed by accident, and reprimanding or rewarding those concerned. This approach is psychologically effective since it is like striking the iron while it is hot. Episodes or incidents centered around experience of everyday occurrence in the life of children can help children identify themselves with them and understand their own thought powers and feelings. Incidents are to be recorded properly and discussed to promote better insight into human problems.
Several attempts have been made to evolve methodologies suitable to the development of values in children and youth.
Douglas Supreka (1976) outlines eight different approaches to value Education, which may be briefly stated as under:
  1. Evocation Approach: The students are encouraged to make spontaneously free, non-rational choices, without thought or hesitation. It provides an environment which allows maximum freedom for students, and provide a provocative situation for which spontaneous reactions are elicited eg. The reaction to a picture of starving children.
  2. Inculcation Approach: Students are forced to act according to specific desired values. A positive and negative reinforcement by the teacher helps value inculcation. This can be done by a teacher's natural actions and responses. This time honored method has been notably unsuccessful.
  3. Awareness Approach: This approach helps students to become aware and identify their own values. The students are encouraged to share their experiences. The teacher presents value laden situations or dilemmas through readings, films, role playing, small group discussions and simulation. Students thus engage themselves in the process of making inferences about values from the thoughts, feelings, beliefs or behavior of themselves and others.
  4. Moral Reasoning Approach: Kohlberg's theory of six stages of moral development is the framework most frequently used in this approach. The teachers setup learning experiences which will facilitate moral development. These experiences fall under the general category of what Kohlberg calls role taking. The critical factor in role taking is empathy. Through placing themselves in a role and experiencing the process of deciding, students can begin to see moral decisions in a larger framework than their single point of view. It consists of the students discussing a dilemma and by reasoning they attain a higher level of knowledge. In this way by discussion and reflection students are encouraged to express a value position rather than compromise on a consensus.
  5. Analysis Approach: the group or individuals are encouraged to study social value problems. They are asked to clarify value questions, and identify values in conflict. They are encouraged to determine the truth and evidence of purported facts, and arrive at value decision, applying analogous cases, inferring and testing value principles underlying the decision.
  6. Value Clarification Approach: It helps students to use both rational thinking and emotional awareness to examine personal behavior patterns and classify and actualize values. This approach has been detailed by Raths et al (1966) and Simon et at (1972) where the child is made to jot down a self _ analysis _ reaction work sheet, consisting of drawings, questions and activities.
  7. Commitment Approach: It enables the students to perceive themselves not merely as passive reactors or as free individuals but as inner-relative members of a social group and system. The Action Project helps to clarify and restructure One's value system and to ascertain the depth of commitment of one's values.
  8. The Union Approach: The purpose is to help students to perceive themselves and act not as separate egos but as part of a larger inter-related whole-the human race, the world, the cosmos.
The Report on the UNESCO APIED on Education for Affective Development has identified the following approaches that can be used for teaching values in character building activities.
  1. Telling: A process for developing values that enables a pupil to have a clear picture of a value _ laden situation by means of his own narration of the situation.
  2. Inculcating: An approach geared towards instilling and internalizing norms into person's own value systems.
  3. Persuading: the process of convincing the learner to accept certain values and behave in accordance with what is acceptable.
  4. Modeling: A strategy in which a certain individual perceived as epitomizing desirable/ideal values is presented to the learners as a model.
  5. Role playing: Acting out the true feelings of the actor(s) by taking the role of another person but without the risk of reprisals.
  6. Simulating: A strategy in which the learners are asked to pretend to be in a certain situation called for by the lesson and then to portray the events and also by imitating the character's personality.
  7. Problem solving: An approach wherein a dilemma is presented to the learners asking them what decisions they are going to take.
  8. Discussing situations, stories, pictures, etc: This technique asks the learners to deliberate on and explain the details in the lesson.
  9. Studying biographies of great men: This is an approach that makes use of the lives of great men as the subject matter for trying to elicit their good needs and thoughts worthy for emulation.
  10. Moralizing: The process of working out a sense of morality through active structuring and restructuring of one's social experiences (e.g. moral reasoning and analysis)
  11. Values clarification: Values clarification as a strategy for values development may be considered as learner-centered. It relies heavily on the pupils ability to process his beliefs, behave according to his beliefs and to make a decision whenever confronted with a value dilemma.


0 comments: